On Brian Moore’s The Lonely Passion of Judith Hearne (1955)

I finished Brian Moore’s The Lonely Passion of Judith Hearne two weeks ago, but am still not sure how to write about it. My reaction to it was very strong; it even gave me nightmares. I wonder if I can do it justice as there’s so much to discuss. It’s excellent and multifaceted and has a lot to say about religion, spinsterhood, family duty, shattered dreams and the woes of being an unattractive woman.

It’s peculiar that after having written two reviews about women who were punished for being too beautiful (Asking For It and Little Deaths), I’m now writing about a book in which the main character suffers, among other things, from being unattractive. Clearly, it’s hard to be a woman.

Judith Hearne is a 40-something spinster who has lived a rather dull and lonely life. Out of a sense of family duty and fuelled by her religious beliefs, she has cared for an ailing aunt until her death. The aunt in question was a rather formidable person and Judith lived under her thumb. Caring for her took up all of Judith’s time. It made it impossible to find love and friendship and now, at 40, she thinks it’s over. Even in her youth she wasn’t good-looking and sadly, age hasn’t made her look interesting. Not yet.

Here’s what she thinks about herself:

She watched the glass, a plain woman, changing all to the delightful illusion of beauty. There was still time: for her ugliness was destined to bloom late, hidden first by the unformed gawkiness of youth, budding to plainness in young womanhood and now flowering to slow maturity in her early forties, it still awaited the subtle garishness which only decay could bring to fruition: a garishness which, when arrived at, would preclude all efforts at the mirror game.

At the beginning of the novel, Judith Hearne has just moved into new lodgings in a shabby boarding house in Belfast. Here’s how the novel begins:

The first thing Miss Judith Hearne unpacked in her new lodging was the silver-framed photograph of her aunt. The place for her aunt, ever since the sad day of the funeral, was on the mantel piece of whatever bed-sitting-room Miss Hearne happened to be living in. And as she put her up now, the photograph eyes were stern and questioning, sharing Miss Hearne’s own misgivings about the condition of the bed-springs, the shabbiness of the furniture and the run-down part of Belfast in which the room was situated.

After she has found a place for her aunt’s picture, she needs to find another one for the Sacred Heart. This beginning shows exactly what kind of person Judith Hearne is. She’s poor and single and the two only things that give her solace are the memory of her aunt and her religion. And a few possessions of value like a watch and pretty shoes with buttons that look like winking eyes.

Judith Hearne is a piano teacher with only a few pupils left. One of the reasons she’s losing pupils is only discovered later in the novel—when things get too stressful, she drinks. Her good education and valuable belongings, catch the eye of one of the other boarders, Mr Madden, the brother of her landlady. Unfortunately, poor Judith thinks he’s really interested. She knows her time is running out and seeing how kind Mr Madden is with her and how he likes to talk to her, gives her hope.

And maybe, although it was a thing you could hardly bear to think about, like death or your last judgment, maybe he would be the last one ever and he would walk away now and it would only be a question of waiting for it all to end and hoping for better things in the next world. But that was silly, it was never too late.

It soon becomes clear that Mr Madden is looking for a business partner, not for a wife. He’s returned from America where he has lived for a long time. According to Miss Hearne, he’s more American than Irish. He lacks manners and dresses differently. If she was honest to herself and not so desperate, she would have to admit that he’s not her type.

Being single might not have been as bad for Judith Hearne if she had friends and family but she doesn’t. There’s only one family she calls her friends, the O’Neill’s. Judith pays them a visit every Sunday. It’s the highlight of her week. She tells herself that they are like family, that the O’Neill kids are like her grandchildren. And she’s sure that they look forward to seeing her too, after all, she goes there well prepared.

For it was important to have things to tell which interested your friends. And Miss Hearne had always been able to find interesting happenings where other people would find only dullness. It was, she often felt, a gift which was one of the great rewards of a solitary life. And a necessary gift. Because, when you were a single girl, you had to find interesting things to talk about. Other women always had their children and shopping and running a house to chat about. Besides which, their husbands often told them interesting stories. But a single girl was in a different position. People simply didn’t want to hear how she managed things like accommodation and budgets. She had to find other subjects and other subjects were mostly other people. So people she knew, people she had heard of, people she saw in the street, people she had read about, they all had to be collected and gone through like a basket of sewing so that the most interesting bits about them could be picked out and fitted together to make conversation.

Brian Moore uses stream-of-consciousness and various points of view to give us an insight into most of his characters thinking. That’s why we know that nobody in this novel thinks kindly about Judith Hearne. Seeing the O’Neill’s before Judith’s arrival on one Sunday is enlightening. Moore is brilliant at unmasking his characters’ feelings and thoughts and knowing what they think and comparing it to what she thinks they think is chilling.

Before moving into this boarding house, Judith Hearne isn’t happy but once things go wrong with Mr Madden, she heads for a crisis. A crisis that unhinges her, because she pretty much loses everything including her faith. The end of the novel, which I won’t describe, tells us how she moves on, after having lost her faith and her illusions.

Different readers will find different things interesting in this book. As someone who was born into a Catholic family, I found the religious aspects especially perturbing.

Just before starting the book, I saw the title of an article about the pope saying he thought it was better to be an atheist than a hypocritical Christian. I couldn’t help but think of this while reading The Lonely Passion of Judith Hearne, a book that is, among other things, very much about just that – religious hypocrisy.

Being rejected by a man, is painful but being let down by her religion and its representative, a priest, is far worse for Judith Hearne.

It’s not often that a title is so well-chosen or that it does double duty like in the case of Moore’s eponymous title. Yes, the book is about loneliness, and it’s about the last hope to find love. But it’s also a description of utter despair and suffering and that’s alluded to in the title as well. After all, “passion” is also a reference to the “passion of the Christ” or his final suffering and martyrdom. We find in this book the same doubts, the same “why have you forsaken me feeling”, only Judith Hearne, being human, has another fate awaiting her.

Before ending, I’d like to say a few words about confession. There’s a heartbreaking scene in this novel, in which Judith Hearne goes to confession. She goes to confess her sin – drinking – but also because she hopes for spiritual help. The scene reminded me of one of Frank O’Connor’s amazing short stories First Confession.

This is a bit of a hodgepodge review and I’m sorry for that. It’s an excellent novel but it reminded me of so much, that it was hard to write about it coherently and I didn’t want to turn this into a memoir piece, telling you all about me and why I left the church. Maybe I’ll do that in another post some day.

The Lonely Passion of Judith Hearne is an excellent novel because Moore is astute. The characters are brilliantly drawn and explored. We see all of their foibles which, at times, is quite funny. The ending however was heartbreaking.

This post is a contribution to  Cathy’s and Raging Fluff’s Reading Ireland Month



45 thoughts on “On Brian Moore’s The Lonely Passion of Judith Hearne (1955)

  1. Sorry about the nightmares. I read this one and really enjoyed it too. No Nightmares. It is a wonderful book–there’s a slight comic edge to it in spite of the dark subject matter. I also read this author’s The Doctor’s Wife which you would love, I think.

    • It’s so sad. Very Eleanor Rigby. I noticed that all of the novels I read recently (Vera Caspary’s novel Laura was another one), had something to do with female beauty or the lack of it.
      Yeah, you can’t win.

  2. I must read more B. Moore. Black Robe was powerful, but this sounds so too, in a different way. Not many male writers trouble to create female protagonists, let alone unglamorous ones (Colm Toibin is the only one I can think of).

    • I must read more of him as well. Black Robe was my first and I was impressed but it’s very different. Toibin does write very well about women too, yes.
      There are a few French authors who write very well about women. Mauriac comes to mind. Although, they might be a bit more glamourous. But Blazac’s Eugénie Grandet would fit.
      Overall, I agree with you.

  3. I read this a year or so ago and it is overwhelmingly sad. The brilliance of Moore’s writing is that outwardly Judith Hearne comes across as quite an irritating, pompous, critical old woman but inwardly she’s fragile and lost. It has the honour of going on to my ‘favourite books of all time’ list.

    I have a couple more of Moore’s books here but I can’t see them being as good as Judith Hearne. I saw the film years ago with Maggie Smith & Bob Hoskins and remember being impressed by Maggie Smith.

    • It is overwhelmingly sad. You’re right about her being pompous and irritating. I hadn’t thought about that. She’s a peculiar mix but possibly being critical is what sustains her for a long time. Thinking that she’s better somehow. When the mask is ripped off her face she crumbles.
      To be honest, I expected something more like The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie and so the book really felt like a punch in the gut.
      Maggie Smith is one of my favourite actresses. I would love to watch the movie.

      • To me the fact that she wasn’t very likeable but we nonetheless end up feeling so much for her was what made it special.

        I’d love to see the film again. It used to appear on UK TV every now and then but I fear it’s one of those ‘forgotten films’ now.

  4. This book sounds very good. I am also interested in many of the issues and themes that it addresses. I was also brought up in aCatholic household and came to be non – believer fairly early on.

    I think that your review is fantastic and I also think that it is fine to write about a book from a personal point of view. There are so many ways that books are interesting and enlightening. How we relate to them personally is one of those ways.

    I am sorry to hear that the book gave you nightmares. I have read fiction that disturbed me a lot too.

    • Thanks for your kind words, Brian.
      It took me a long time to be able to write about it. I could have written a lot more about the Catholic faith, confession and some things that go really wrong in the Catholic church. This new pope seems a bit more liberal, kinder, I feel but I’m an anticlerical and that’s not going to chnage but religion, spirituality . . . It’s very important to me. I don’t normally react this strongly. I guess I was in a weird phase. But it’s a very sad book. Full of interesting themes though.

  5. I love this review and I love how both of us have read the same book for the ‘Reading Ireland Month’, Caroline. 🙂 The book broke my heart. Every character, grey and beautiful and cruel, were beautiful in their own ways. I want to read more of Moore’s.

    • I think so too. For a while he was very successful in Germany. Every book was translated and received praise, almost more than in English speaking countries.

  6. The only one of his books that I read was The Luck of Ginger Coffey and I think I felt much the way you’ve described here, but no nightmares, fortunately (but what a statement about how much the story affected you – wow!). His ability to get under the skins of characters, who are struggling in quiet and dramatic ways, is pretty amazing, I think. I wasn’t expecting the darkness either. IIRC, there is a good bit of discussion about his writing in one of Diana Athill’s memoirs, which also was interesting.

    • It’s very affecting. Of course, it wasn’t a “monsters under the bed” type nightmare, more one of quiet but profound despair.
      The book was very dark. Interesting that you had a similar experience. I don’t have that book. I don’t even think I’ve heard of that one. I won’t rush to pick it up as I had my dose of sad stories.
      In the future maybe.
      Very interesting about Diana Athill’s memoirs. I’ve got two of them, so that will be very interesting.

  7. Beautiful review, Caroline! I haven’t heard of Brian Moore before and so am excited to have discovered a new author. Thank you! I loved that passage that you have quoted on how a single woman finds topics for conversation. So beautiful! It is sad that Judith Hearne’s life takes the turns it did and it is sad that the ending is heartbreaking. Thanks for this beautiful review!

  8. I read this quite a few years ago, but it made such an impression on me that I still carry parts of the story around with me. I remember feeling so angry about the fate of women like Judith, who lived miserable lives on the fringes of society, because they were poor or not very attractive, or because they’d spent their youth taking care of someone else and now they were considered too old, or too odd, to be of any further “use”. As an atheist, I kind of expected the religious hypocrisy, but it was still shocking. I think of all those sad women, and there must have been a lot of them, who nobody wanted and everyone despised. I was really affected by the book, and thought it was a brilliant bit of writing.

    • I’m glad to hear you felt the same. It is brilliant and infuriating and sad. Im not sure what shocked me the most. The religious hypocrisy or the fact that nobody seemed to like her, the way her illusions were shattered.

  9. Pingback: Best Books I Read 2017 | Beauty is a Sleeping Cat

  10. Pingback: The Lonely Passion of Judith Hearne by Brian Moore for #BrianMoore100

Thanks for commenting, I love to hear your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.