Madeleine St.John: The Women in Black (1993)

With the lightest touch and the most tender of comic instincts, Madeleine St John conjures a vanished summer of innocence. The Women In Black is a great novel, a lost Australian classic.

Madeleine St. John wasn’t on my initial list of authors for the Aussie Author Challenge but after one of Litlove’s (Tales From the Reading Room) comments I thought I’d like to read one of her books and picked The Women in Black. Coincidentally Litlove reviewed it recently as well as you can see here.

The Women in Black is Madeleine St. John’s first novel. She wrote it at the age of 52. It was followed by three other novels which, unlike the first, were not set in St. John’s native Sidney but in London where the author had been living since the 60s. The book is set in the 50s in Sidney and takes place to a large extent in a famous department store, just before the Christmas rush, on the floor of Cocktail Frocks and Model Gowns. It centers on a little group of interestingly different women, Patty, married to Frank (the brute), Mrs. Jacob, the mysterious, Fay, the thirtysomething single woman, Lisa aka Lesley the assistant (temporary) and Magda, the glamorous European refugee who has more elegance and style than all of them together.

Magda and Lisa are the characters where most of the other stories converge and are the indicators that this novel, as lovely, bubbly and playful as it seems, still is a satirical comedy of manners, depicting a society undergoing great change. One of those changes concerns the status of women. No longer only dependent housewives, this decade sees the first female university students who want more than just a husband and children.

When you have a confined environment like an office, a hotel, a shop or anything like this, a newcomer like Lisa, is sure to stir things up, no matter how kind and nice the person is. Lisa is a new type of Australian woman, one that has only recently emerged, more interested in books and studying than attracting a husband.

“A clever girl is the most wonderful thing in all creation you know: you must never forget that. People expect men to be clever. They expect girls to be stupid or at least silly, which very few girls really are, but most girls oblige them by acting like it. So you just go away and be as clever as ever you can: put their noses out of joint for them. It’s the best thing you could possibly do, you and all the clever girls in this city and the world.”

The World depicted in The Women in Black is gone. The importance for a woman to attract a man has considerably diminished, it isn’t exotic for a woman to study and the composite post-war society, mixing European refugees and born Australians, has certainly become more homogenous. At the time however it seems, Europe is as far as the moon and the ways of its people quite exotic which is a source of comedy for St. John.

“Do Russians count as Continentals?” she asked Myra. “Who are you thinking of?” asked Myra. “Oh, no one in particular,” said Fay. “I just wondered.” “Well, I suppose they do, ” said Myra. “But you know they’re not allowed out, Russians. You never really see any Russians, do you? They are all in Russia.” “I suppose you’re right, ” said Fay. “Still, if they were allowed out, they’d be Continentals, don’t you think?” “Oh yes, I reckon so, ” said Myra. “All them peoples are Continentals.”

This is a witty and cheerful novel in which each chapter is like a vignette and tells episodes of the one or the other woman’s story. As much as it depicts a change of values it shows that some things will always be of importance to women and much of this is reflected by the clothes and gowns sold at the department store. The power of dresses and fashion cannot be underestimated. A beautiful dress, sexy lingerie can become more than just a piece of garment, it can tie you down or free you.

Lisa stood gazing her fill. She was experiencing for the first time that particular species of love-at-first-sight which usually comes to a woman much earlier in her life, but which sooner or later comes to all: the sudden recognition that a particular frock is not merely pretty, would not merely suit one, but answers beyond these necessary attributes to ne’s deepest notions of oneself. It was her frock: it had been made, however unwittingly for her.

I enjoyed this a lot, and was reminded of my grand-mother who supplied Haute Couture dressmakers with haberdashery. I still have some of her elegant gloves and scarves, even some of her handbags and a black evening coat. It made me very nostalgic to read about the changes linked to clothes. Lisa’s mother sows a lot of her daughter’s clothes, alters them, mends them. Nowadays we just throw them away, buy something new. Only the most expensive Haute Couture dresses are still handmade.

As I said, it’s a cheerful novel that captures a changing society and a vanished world. It’s not free of social criticism but it manages to show that even this long-gone era with its antiquated beliefs had its charm. There are infuriating moments and people in the book, mostly men who repress women and the women who support them, but each negative character gets a chance to develop. The positive habits of one character are passed on to another one and all of them win something in the end. Lisa, for example is a reader and when she passes on her copy of Anna Karenina to Fay this isn’t only a symbol – shortly afterwards, she meets a nice Hungarian man – but reading literature is a new habit. There are many instances like this in the novel. Maybe at some other time I would have found this to be overly optimistic but it was exactly what I needed after my last readalong title.

If you want to spend a few moments with a cheerful and intelligent book, this is one you shouldn’t miss.

The Women in Black is my first contribution to the Aussie Author Challenge 2012.

22 thoughts on “Madeleine St.John: The Women in Black (1993)

  1. I read this a few years back and liked it very much. I’ve been intending to get back to this author for some time. Like you I also want to read more Aussie lit this year and that’s thanks to knowing Aussie blogger, Gummie and transplanted Tony.

    • I was thinking of you when reading this and was sure she is someone you would like. She seems to have been quite a character as well.
      I have much more Aussie books than I thought when I did my sign up post and am looking forwad to read my way through them. What would we do without our fellow bloggers over there… I’ve been thinking of transplantig as well but the kitty importation fee 5000$ + quarantine for I don’t know how long is daunting. I’m fed up with Europe at the moment. No space here.

      • We almost emigrated to Australia when I was a child. I have relatives there in Sydney. When I read an Aussie book or watch an Aussie film I always have one of those “I could have been an Australian” moments.

        That’s a crazy fee. Someone is getting fat from that.

        • And if you were there you would maybe think I could have been an American.
          Yes, it’s an incredible amount. That’s bad enough although the quarantine is worse. I don’t think my cats would survive that.

  2. glad you like this book better than your previous one.
    I really really your first quote…I think the same as that quote.
    The writer amazed me, first book at age 50…wow!!! I never thought such thing exist.

    • I was glad as well. 🙂
      It’s agreat quote, isn’t it?
      I think there are a lot of writers who start quite late only nobody speaks about it much. People always think it’s admirable to achieve everything when you are young but it’s not. Better late than never.

  3. Nice review, Caroline! Glad to know that you enjoyed this book. Aussie Author Challenge has well and truly started 🙂 It is amazing that not a long time back, things were so different for women. It must have been so tough during those times. When pioneers like Lisa (in the novel) come along it must have been like a breath of fresh air. It is nice to know that your grandmother gave you many beautiful things.

    • Thanks, Vishy. I’m glad the challenge had such a great start, I’m really in the mood for more Australian literature now. It seems not all that long ago but in terms of chnage it’s far away. I truly admire these women who despite so much adversity did what they felt was right.
      My grandmother left me a lot of really nice things. I should take a few pictures one of these days. 🙂

  4. I’ll read your review later when I read the book. It’s been on my shelves for a few months, I bought it after Lisa reviewed it (ANZ Lit Lovers)

  5. I remember Litlove’s post and this reminds me that I want to try and get a copy of this book, which I can’t unfortunately find at my library. I like books that are seemningly charming, but have a nice depth to them still and this sounds just like that. Definitely a good choice after reading Barry!

    • It was the perfect choice. I liked it very much and wouldn’t have minded if it had been longer It’s very short. Barely 160 pages. I’m quite keen on reading more of her books. I hope you will try it. I’m sure you will like it.

Thanks for commenting, I love to hear your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.